Readers debate Nintendo's next big hit after Zelda remake release
With Splatoon Raiders and Fire Emblem sales in, fans wonder what A-list title follows, while others critique the Ocarina of Time update.
By Beatriz Soto ·
The video game community is currently divided over the direction of Nintendo’s upcoming releases, with readers weighing in on the publisher’s recent sales data and the new Ocarina of Time remake.
Nintendo disclosed its latest financial figures, showing that Star Fox has sold 1.17 million copies since late June. Fire Emblem: Fortune’s Weave has moved 1.34 million units since its September launch, a figure readers noted as strong given the game’s higher price point. Splatoon Raiders, released in July, has sold 2.42 million copies, a number that falls short of the 11 million sold by Splatoon 3.
Reader Prof. Blue argued that these titles represent B-tier franchises and questioned when the next major A-list title would arrive. The reader noted that Metroid, Kirby, and Xenoblade are already announced for next year, as is a new Pokemon game, but asked for proof that a new Super Mario title is in development.
The release of the Ocarina of Time remake has also sparked debate about Nintendo’s creative approach. Reader Marc described the game as a mostly one-to-one redo, suggesting that the publisher is relying on nostalgia rather than innovation. Marc compared this strategy to other recent remakes that altered the original formula and expressed concern about the company's current direction.
In response, the Metro games team noted that the remake serves as an alternative to Breath of the Wild and that the next mainline game will be something different. They argued that the 40th anniversary remake is not the place for major reinvention.
Other readers focused on physical media and collectibles. Freeway 77 reported receiving a foil-covered version of the game on release day and praised the visual upgrades to Hyrule Town. The reader suggested that Nintendo could have included Master Quest content via amiibo, a proposal the games team acknowledged but noted might face resistance from fans who prefer amiibo to offer only cosmetic extras.
The discussion also touched on Sony's recent performance. Reader Colin expressed worry about the delay of God of War Laufey, noting that it was moved due to a busy month. Colin pointed out that recent first-party titles like God of War Sons of Sparta and Marvel's Wolverine have not achieved massive sales figures, prompting speculation that Sony might rethink its strategy if current titles underperform.
Reader Bobwallett offered a mixed view on Bethesda's upcoming Elder Scrolls game, hoping it would be better received than Skyrim. The reader mentioned leaving Starfield untouched on a shelf and suggested that Bethesda needs to focus on making the game fun and worth playing, similar to their approach with Fallout 76.
The letters also included recommendations for indie racing games. Kurt Lewin praised Super Woden: Rally Edge for its handling and PS1-style campaign, and highlighted Parking Garage Rally Circuit for its depth and European car park DLC. The reader requested a code for LeMan Racing, which the games team promised to send shortly.
The inbox also covered a deep discount for Silent Hill f on PSN, priced at 15.39 pounds until the 20th of this month, which the games team recommended. Nick The Greek asked if a dedicated jump button in the Zelda remake complicates gameplay, to which the team replied that it is a minor adjustment for casual players but negligible for experienced gamers.
